Why New Shingles Aren’t Laying Flat: Solutions & Tips

Written By Kevin Kabaria

Introduction

Did you know that improper shingle installation can lead to leaks, costing homeowners an average of $1,500 in repairs (source: HomeAdvisor)? For homeowners, ensuring that new shingles lay flat is crucial for both aesthetic appeal and roof longevity. If your new shingles are not lying flat, understanding the root causes can save you from costly repairs down the line. In this post, we'll explore why new shingles might not lay flat, focusing on issues like installation errors, weather impacts, and manufacturing quality. You'll also discover practical solutions to address these challenges, ensuring your roof remains both beautiful and functional.

Table of Contents

Understanding Why New Shingles Won't Lay Flat

When you invest in a new roof, you expect your shingles to lie flat. However, sometimes new shingles don't lay flat, which can be a common issue. Understanding the causes can help you find a solution. Shingles that don’t lie flat can lead to leaks and a shorter roof lifespan, as water can pool in raised areas and exposed areas can wear down faster. Let's explore the reasons why your new shingles might not be lying flat, including installation issues, weather conditions, and manufacturing quality.

Common Installation Problems

Improper installation is a major reason why shingles don't lay flat. This often includes mistakes such as using too few nails, incorrect nail placement, or poor shingle alignment. According to industry sources, using too few nails can allow shingles to lift in the wind. Incorrect nail placement (too high or too low) can also be a problem. Nails should be driven straight and at the proper depth. Poor shingle alignment can create gaps and ridges. Hiring unqualified contractors often leads to these errors, as they may lack the experience and attention to detail needed for proper shingle installation. For example, an unqualified contractor might not understand proper shingle overlap or might use the wrong nailing patterns. Poor installation not only looks bad but can cause leaks and premature roof aging. Improperly installed shingles can create channels for water to collect and seep underneath, damaging the roof structure, which can lead to costly repairs. A clean, flat roof deck is also important. Laying new shingles over old ones can create an uneven surface, making it harder for the new shingles to lie flat. Choosing an experienced, qualified contractor and ensuring a proper roof deck can help your shingles lay flat. Consider scheduling a Get Your Roof Assessment for a professional evaluation.

Common Installation Mistakes

  • Using too few nails
  • Incorrect nail placement
  • Poor shingle alignment

Consequences

  • Shingles lifting in the wind
  • Gaps and ridges formation
  • Premature roof aging

Temperature and Weather Effects

Temperature and weather greatly affect how shingles lay flat. Shingles perform best when installed in moderate temperatures, ideally above 50°F. Extreme temperatures affect the adhesive. Roofing contractors often prefer spring and fall for installations due to the milder temperatures. The adhesive needs the right temperature to cure properly. Cold weather (below 40°F) can make shingles brittle and difficult to work with, increasing the risk of cracking. Extreme heat can warp the shingles or soften the adhesive too much, making them difficult to align. New shingles may initially appear wavy because the adhesive hasn't fully set. This usually resolves once the temperature stabilizes and the adhesive cures. This is normal and typically not a concern. A slightly wavy appearance might remain, but it shouldn't affect the roof's performance. Installing shingles during mild weather helps them lay flat. Even with good weather, shingles need time to adhere completely. You can learn more about roof maintenance to understand how weather affects your roof.

Weather Effects on Shingles

  • Cold weather: Makes shingles brittle
  • Extreme heat: Can warp shingles
  • Mild weather: Ideal for installation

Optimal Installation Conditions

  • Temperature above 50°F
  • Spring or Fall
  • Allow time for adhesive to set

Manufacturing Quality Standards

The quality of the shingles also affects how well they lay flat. Lower-quality shingles are more likely to warp and curl. This prevents them from lying flat on the roof. This can be due to inconsistencies in materials or the manufacturing process. Manufacturers use strict quality control to minimize defects. These measures include testing and inspections to catch problems before products reach consumers. For example, manufacturers inspect shingles for consistent thickness, proper adhesive, and tear resistance. These quality control measures ensure a more uniform and reliable product. Choose shingles from reputable manufacturers known for high quality. Look for warranties that cover manufacturing defects, which usually cover replacing defective shingles but not labor for reinstallation. Understand what the warranty covers before you buy.

Critical Installation Requirements

Installing new shingles might seem straightforward, but many factors can affect the outcome. Common issues, like shingles not laying flat, often arise from overlooking key installation details. Understanding these requirements can prevent costly repairs later, such as fixing leaks or replacing damaged shingles due to faulty installation. Industry data shows that construction defects can lead to significant expenses. This section covers three crucial aspects: proper nailing techniques, temperature guidelines, and storage and handling best practices. Mastering these areas helps avoid common pitfalls and extends the life of your roof. Consider scheduling a Get Your Roof Assessment to identify potential issues early on.

Proper Nailing Techniques

Correct nailing is vital for shingle installation. Improper nailing can cause shingles to lie unevenly, become vulnerable to wind damage, or even blow off in storms.

Nail Quantity and Placement

Typically, four nails per shingle suffice. However, in high-wind areas, six nails provide extra security, enhancing resistance against wind uplift. Place nails precisely, keeping nail heads at least one inch from shingle edges. This distributes the load and prevents tearing, ensuring secure fastening to the roof deck. Avoid nailing into knot holes, as these weak points compromise the hold.

Following Manufacturer Guidelines

Manufacturers provide diagrams illustrating optimal nail placement patterns, often including designated "high nailing areas" and "low nailing areas" on the shingle. Adhering to these guidelines ensures maximum hold and proper shingle function. For wood shingles, the pattern differs, usually requiring two nails per shingle, placed about an inch from each edge and an inch above the overlap. This accommodates the wood's expansion and contraction.

Nail Placement Guidelines

  • Four nails per shingle
  • Six nails in high-wind areas
  • Avoid nailing into knot holes

Manufacturer Guidelines

  • Follow nail placement diagrams
  • Adhere to high and low nailing areas
  • Ensure proper shingle function

Temperature Guidelines

Installation temperature significantly impacts shingle performance and lifespan. Moderate weather is ideal, avoiding extremes that can cause damage.

Roofing contractors advise installations between 50°F and 85°F. Spring and fall often offer the best conditions. Above 80°F, shingles can become too pliable, potentially sticking together during storage or application. Below 40°F, shingles become brittle and prone to cracking during handling or fastening. Maintaining the right temperature range ensures shingles retain their shape and adhere correctly.

Worker Comfort and Safety

While ideal installation temperatures fall below 80°F, temperatures in the 50s, 60s, and low 70s are preferable for worker comfort, given the direct sun exposure on a roof. Extreme heat can create strenuous and potentially hazardous working conditions.

Storage and Handling Best Practices

Proper storage and handling, even before installation, are crucial for shingle performance.

Storage Recommendations

Store shingles in a cool, dry location to prevent moisture absorption, which can lead to premature roof failure and leaks. Follow manufacturer guidelines on stacking bundles to avoid deformation from excessive weight.

Handling Precautions

Mishandling shingles, particularly in cold weather, can cause cracking or breakage. Careful handling is essential. Cold asphalt becomes brittle and easily damaged by impacts or bending. Proper storage and handling ensure shingles remain flat after installation. Learn more about roof maintenance to understand the long-term impact of proper installation.

Warranty Considerations

Adhering to manufacturer storage and handling recommendations is often a warranty condition. Ignoring these guidelines could void the warranty, leaving you liable for repair costs. By following these critical installation requirements—proper nailing, attention to temperature, and careful storage and handling—you can minimize common shingle installation problems. These practices are essential for a flat, secure, and durable roof. For a professional evaluation, consider a Get Your Roof Assessment.

Understanding Warranty Terms

Carefully review your shingle warranty's terms and conditions. Coverage often includes repair or replacement of defective shingles, but labor costs may not be included. Some warranties cover the shingles but not the installation labor. Check for proration schedules, which reduce coverage as the shingles age.

Leveraging Warranty for Cost Savings

If your shingles are under warranty, contact the manufacturer to discuss coverage for your non-flat shingles. Explain the issue and provide documentation like photos. Using your warranty can greatly reduce repair or replacement costs. The manufacturer might provide free replacement shingles or offer a discount. Ensure all roof work complies with the warranty to avoid voiding it. Improper installation, for example, can void your warranty. In conclusion, addressing the issue of shingles not laying flat requires a comprehensive approach. Understanding repair costs, insurance options, and warranty coverage empowers homeowners to make informed decisions that balance cost with effective roof management. Taking the time to research these aspects can save you money and ensure a long-lasting, well-functioning roof.

Weather and Environmental Factors

Understanding the impact of weather and environmental factors on roofing shingles is crucial for ensuring their longevity and effectiveness. The weather conditions during installation, and ongoing environmental factors, significantly influence whether shingles lay flat. Problems like warping or buckling can also occur. This section explores optimal installation temperatures, humidity's effects, and seasonal considerations for new shingle performance. This information helps homeowners and contractors make informed decisions to prevent roofing problems and improve roof lifespan. Consider scheduling a Get Your Roof Assessment to identify potential weather-related issues.

Optimal Temperature Ranges

Temperature plays a key role in shingle installation and performance. The ideal range is typically between 50°F and 85°F (10°C and 29°C). Several sources support this range as optimal for shingle flexibility and adhesion. Within this range, shingles are flexible enough to conform to the roof deck and seal correctly.

Low Temperatures

Shingles installed below 50°F may become brittle and difficult to work with, leading to misalignment, cracking, and potential damage.

High Temperatures

Temperatures above 85°F can make shingles too soft and sticky, increasing the risk of them sticking together during installation, preventing them from laying flat and potentially causing buckling later.

Temperature Fluctuations

Avoid installation if temperatures are expected to fall below 40°F or exceed 85°F at any point during the process. Even short periods outside the optimal range can negatively impact shingle properties and long-term performance.

Temperature Effects on Shingles

  • Below 50°F: Brittle and misaligned
  • Above 85°F: Too soft and sticky
  • Maintain 50°F - 85°F for best results

Installation Tips

  • Avoid extremes in temperature
  • Plan for stable conditions
  • Allow time for adhesive setting

Humidity Impact

Humidity, the amount of water vapor in the air, significantly affects roofing materials. High humidity can cause shingles to absorb moisture, leading to swelling and warping over time. This prevents new shingles from laying flat by altering their shape and flexibility. Excess moisture can also interfere with the shingle adhesive, hindering proper bonding to the underlayment.

The American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) and the US EPA recommend 30-50% indoor humidity for comfort and health. While this pertains to indoor humidity, it illustrates how excess moisture can harm building materials like shingles.

Ventilation

Proper attic ventilation is essential, especially in humid climates, to allow moisture to escape and prevent long-term damage. Good ventilation regulates moisture and prevents humidity buildup that can cause warping and other issues. Learn more about roof maintenance to understand the importance of ventilation.

Seasonal Considerations

Seasonal temperature and humidity changes affect shingle installation and performance. Spring and fall generally offer ideal conditions due to moderate temperatures and relatively stable weather. These seasons reduce the risk of weather delays and material damage from heavy rain or snow.

Summer and Winter Challenges

Summer heat can soften shingles, hindering adhesion. Winter cold can make them brittle, increasing the risk of cracking during installation. Scheduling projects during temperate months like spring or fall ensures proper installation and reduces the need for costly repairs.

Mild Climates

Even in mild climates, consider daily temperature fluctuations. Avoid installation during excessively hot or cold periods for optimal results. Adhering to the ideal temperature window, regardless of climate, ensures proper shingle adhesion and performance.

Material Composition and Quality

Understanding the material composition and quality of shingles is crucial for a durable, high-performing roof. Different shingle types, like fiberglass and organic, have unique properties that influence how they lie on a roof. Weight, for example, plays a role; shingles typically weigh between 15 and 40 pounds. Heavier shingles may take longer to settle onto the roof deck. Manufacturing standards and quality testing also ensure shingles meet industry standards and avoid defects. This section explores these factors to explain why new shingles might not lay flat.

Fiberglass vs Organic Shingles

Fiberglass and organic shingles are the two main types of asphalt shingles, each with distinct characteristics. Fiberglass shingles feature a woven fiberglass base mat coated with waterproof asphalt and topped with ceramic granules. These granules shield the shingles from the sun's harmful UV rays, boosting their durability. The asphalt coating consists of asphalt cement (30-36%), felt (2-15%), mineral aggregate (20-38%), and mineral filler (8-40%). This layered design provides waterproofing and weather resistance. Organic shingles, conversely, use a cellulose (felt or fiber) base, making them heavier and potentially less moisture-resistant than fiberglass shingles. This difference in moisture resistance can affect how shingles react to rain or humidity after installation. Organic shingles may absorb more moisture, potentially leading to warping or curling. Fiberglass shingles are lighter, making them easier to install and less stressful on a roof's structure. This lighter weight allows them to conform to the roof deck more easily. Synthetic underlayment, made from polyethylene or polypropylene polymers, often accompanies these shingles. This enhances moisture protection and provides a smooth installation surface. This underlayment adds another layer of leak protection and creates a uniform surface for shingle adhesion. Fiberglass shingles also hold a Class A fire rating, offering superior fire resistance compared to organic options. This provides the highest level of fire protection available for roofing materials. Considering these factors can help you make an informed decision and potentially prevent issues down the line. Want a professional assessment? Get Your Roof Assessment

Fiberglass Shingles

  • Woven fiberglass base
  • Coated with waterproof asphalt
  • Lightweight and easier to install
  • Class A fire rating

Organic Shingles

  • Cellulose base (felt or fiber)
  • Heavier and less moisture-resistant
  • May absorb more moisture
  • Potential for warping or curling

Manufacturing Standards

Strict manufacturing standards are essential for producing high-quality shingles that lay flat and perform well. Organizations like ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials) set guidelines for manufacturing to ensure consistency and quality. These standards govern shingle composition and production, supporting manufacturers' quality control. For example, ASTM standards address the testing of fiber-cement flat sheets, roofing shingles, siding shingles, and clapboards, encompassing both smooth and textured surfaces. This comprehensive approach ensures various shingle types meet quality benchmarks. By adhering to these guidelines, manufacturers minimize defects and ensure shingles meet durability and performance criteria. These standards also help manufacturers improve production if defects arise, leading to better shingle quality. Learn more about how maintaining your roof can save you money in the long run.

Quality Testing Procedures

Quality testing is vital for verifying that shingles meet standards and perform as expected. Various tests assess shingle durability, moisture resistance, and overall quality. These tests ensure shingles can withstand different weather conditions and maintain their integrity. Nondestructive testing standards, like those from ASTM, are used to find and evaluate flaws without causing damage. These tests often use common inspection instruments and follow industry standards, specifying testing methods, frequency, and equipment calibration. This rigorous process ensures accurate results, identifying potential issues like inconsistent thickness or hidden cracks. This allows manufacturers to address defects before shingles reach consumers, leading to higher quality and a lower likelihood of issues like shingles not laying flat. This translates to a more reliable, longer-lasting roof.

Professional Installation Best Practices

Achieving a flat, durable shingle installation begins with following professional best practices. These practices ensure your roof system's longevity and performance, minimizing issues like shingles not laying flat. This section explores key areas needing attention: proper ventilation, underlayment preparation, and nail placement. By following these methods, homeowners can rest assured their roof is installed correctly and ready to withstand the elements.

Proper Ventilation Requirements

Proper ventilation is crucial for any roof. It extends roof life by preventing moisture buildup and extreme temperatures in the attic. According to industry sources like "Why Ventilation is Important," proper attic ventilation is the flow of outside air through the space beneath the roof deck. This helps prevent problems like mold, ice dams, and high energy bills. The U.S. Federal Housing Authority recommends at least 1 square foot of ventilation for every 300 square feet of attic space, split evenly between intake and exhaust. This is the 1/300 rule. This balance is essential for good airflow, reducing premature roof failure from excess heat or moisture. Building codes and shingle manufacturers often require this minimum ventilation. Poor ventilation can lead to mold, winter ice dams, and higher energy costs. For optimal ventilation, place intake vents near the soffits (the roof overhang's underside) and exhaust vents near the ridge (the roof's peak). This creates balanced airflow. For a comprehensive guide to roof maintenance, learn more about roof maintenance.

Underlayment Preparation

Proper underlayment preparation is key to defending against water damage. Underlayment acts as a secondary barrier against water, especially during storms. It's an extra layer of leak protection. Underlayment is typically made of asphalt-saturated felt or synthetic materials. Options include traditional felt (like tar paper) and modern synthetics. Synthetic underlayment, like Owens Corning Deck Defense, offers better durability and weather resistance than felt. Apply underlayment horizontally up the roof, overlapping each layer by at least 2 inches on the sides and 4 inches at the ends. This overlapping prevents water from seeping through. Trim and fit the underlayment at the roof peak to cover the entire deck. This meets fire-resistance standards like ASTM E108/UL790, a crucial safety requirement. Using the same brand of underlayment and shingles is often recommended for best results.

Underlayment Types

  • Asphalt-saturated felt
  • Synthetic materials
  • Synthetic offers better durability

Installation Tips

  • Overlap layers by 2-4 inches
  • Trim to fit roof peak
  • Follow fire-resistance standards

Nail Placement Guidelines

Correct nailing is essential to secure shingles and prevent lifting. Typically, four nails per shingle are standard, but six are recommended in high-wind areas for added security. Each nail should be driven along the designated nail line, usually marked on the shingle. These lines show the best nail placement to secure the shingle without damage. Place nails at least 1 inch from the shingle's edge, following the manufacturer's instructions for specific patterns. Avoid nailing into knot holes, which weakens the hold, or using the wrong nail size. These mistakes can compromise the roof and lead to costly repairs. Incorrect nailing techniques, including improper nail exposure and penetration depth, can also shorten roof lifespan. Nail heads should be flush with the shingle to prevent water from seeping in. Overdriving or underdriving nails can cause problems. Following these guidelines strengthens the bond between shingle layers and improves overall roof performance. Consider a professional roof assessment to ensure proper nail placement and identify potential issues.

Timeline for Proper Settling

Understanding how long it takes for new shingles to settle is important for a strong, long-lasting roof. After installation, shingles need time to stick firmly and lie flat. This settling time depends on things like the shingle type (asphalt, wood, etc.) and the weather. Not waiting long enough can lead to costly repairs later. For example, wind can get under shingles that haven't sealed, letting water into your home. This section explains the difference between summer and winter installations, expected settling times, and what normal settling looks like.

Summer vs Winter Installation

The season your shingles are installed in makes a big difference in how long they take to settle. In warm summer months, shingles settle faster because of the higher temperatures. This usually takes about a week. The warm weather softens asphalt shingles, helping them fit snugly against the roof. Winter installations are different. When it's colder than 40°F, settling can take a month or two, or even longer. This is because the shingles are less flexible in the cold. In Minnesota, roofers avoid installing shingles when the average temperature dips into the 40s. Roofing contractors suggest spring and fall for installations to avoid extreme temperatures. The best conditions are above 50°F and dry. Warmth and dryness are key for shingles to stick properly. If you must install shingles in winter, a heat gun can warm them up before installation, helping them settle faster, especially for less flexible materials like wood shingles. This helps the adhesive work even when it's cold.

Expected Settlement Period

How long shingles take to settle depends a lot on the weather and shingle type. In warm weather, it might only take a week. In colder weather, it can take several weeks to a couple of months. Even a few warm days during a cold spell can help speed things up. The adhesive on shingles is activated by heat. It's important to let the shingles settle completely before bad weather hits. Rain or strong winds before they've sealed can cause problems and extra costs. Wind can lift or tear shingles that aren't sealed, causing leaks. When planning a new roof, think about your local climate. Knowing your typical weather helps you estimate the settling time. Consider getting a roof assessment to help understand your specific needs.

Signs of Normal Settling

Knowing what normal settling looks like helps you spot potential problems. New shingles often look a little bumpy or raised at first. This is normal, especially with certain shingle types and in certain weather. It just means they haven't fully stuck to the roof yet. As they settle, they'll flatten out and look smooth. This happens as the adhesive strips on the back are activated by heat and pressure. If your shingles stay raised or don't settle after a reasonable time (several weeks in warm weather, several months in cold), there might be a problem. It could be faulty installation, bad shingles, or something else. For example, if nails aren't driven in correctly, it can affect settling. Keep an eye on your new shingles. Catching problems early can prevent bigger issues and ensure your roof lasts. You can learn more about roof maintenance to ensure your roof stays in top condition.

Warning Signs and Troubleshooting

Identifying potential issues with your newly installed shingles early can save you money and prevent extensive damage. One of the most obvious signs of trouble is when your shingles do not lay flat. This can indicate improper installation or material defects. This section guides you through common red flags, when to seek professional help, and emergency temporary fixes. By understanding these warning signs and how to address them, you can ensure the longevity and effectiveness of your roofing system. Consider scheduling a Get Your Roof Assessment for a comprehensive evaluation.

Common Red Flags

Loose or missing shingles are significant red flags. These issues often arise from improper installation, such as incorrect nailing patterns or inadequate sealant. Strong winds or severe weather can worsen the problem, leading to further damage like water infiltration or additional shingle loss. Inspecting your shingles and addressing any issues promptly can prevent more significant problems. Learn more about roof maintenance.

Improper Nailing Patterns

Incorrect nailing patterns are another common issue. On traditional 3-tab shingles, nails should be placed just below the tar line and away from the middle of each shingle. This placement, often a 6-nail high wind nailing pattern, prevents wind uplift and water seepage. Incorrectly placed nails can compromise shingle integrity and water resistance.

Weather significantly impacts shingle performance. In cold weather, shingles can become brittle and crack, potentially breaking during installation. Handle shingles carefully in cold weather. After storms, inspect your roof for damage or displacement. High winds can tear shingles off, and hail can cause dents and cracks, impacting their resistance.

Red Flags

  • Loose or missing shingles
  • Improper nailing patterns
  • Weather-related damage

Common Causes

  • Improper installation
  • Severe weather events
  • Inadequate sealant

When to Seek Professional Help

While some roofing issues have simple fixes, others require professional help. Persistent leaks, widespread shingle displacement, or visible structural damage warrant a professional roofer. They can assess the situation and recommend repairs or replacement. This is especially important if the damage is extensive or you're uncomfortable working on your roof. Even minor defects can become costly if not addressed.

Assessing the Severity

Professionals assess the severity of shingle problems and provide appropriate solutions. They can identify underlying issues like structural damage or improper installation, preventing costly future repairs. For example, they can determine if the roof deck is damaged or if shingles were installed correctly.

Emergency Temporary Fixes

Sometimes, you need temporary fixes until professional help arrives. Cover damaged areas with a tarp to prevent water damage. Secure the tarp tightly.

Quick Repairs

You can temporarily secure a few loose shingles with roofing cement or nails. Use roofing nails designed for shingles. Correct nail type and placement ensure a proper seal. However, these are temporary solutions and shouldn't replace professional repairs. Regularly checking your roof and making quick repairs can mitigate damage until a permanent solution is in place. Remember, these are short-term fixes; contact a professional as soon as possible.

Cost Considerations and Solutions

When your new shingles aren't laying flat, it's important to understand the costs involved. While the appearance of curled or buckled shingles is a concern, the potential for leaks and the financial implications add another layer of complexity. This section helps you understand the costs of repair vs. replacement, your insurance options, and how your warranty might help. Considering these factors will guide you toward the best solution.

Repair Cost Ranges

Repairing shingles that aren't lying flat varies in cost. Factors like the extent of the problem and the shingle type influence the final price. Generally, roof repairs cost between $379 and $1,758. This includes labor, materials like sealant and replacement shingles, and any necessary equipment. Minor issues, like a few lifted tabs or a small buckled area, are often best addressed with repairs. This is a cost-effective solution for minor damage. However, if the problem affects over 25% of your roof, a full replacement may be more economical in the long run. Repairing a large area can quickly become as expensive as a new roof. Replacing a standard asphalt shingle roof typically costs between $3 and $5 per square foot, totaling $5,700 to $12,000 on average. It's essential to balance the initial savings of a repair against the risk of recurring problems and further expenses. For example, if the root cause of the lifting isn't fixed, the repaired shingles might lift again. While repairs may initially cost between $300 and $1,000 (depending on the damage), older roofs often require more frequent repairs.

Factors Affecting Repair Costs

Several factors influence shingle repair costs. The roofing material plays a significant role. High-end materials like slate or tile are typically more expensive to repair than standard asphalt shingles. Metal roofs, for instance, cost between $7 and $14 per square foot for materials alone, with total costs (including installation) reaching $9 to $20 per square foot. The extent of the damage also matters. A small damaged area is much cheaper to fix than widespread buckling. Other cost factors include local labor rates and the roof's complexity. A steep, multi-angled roof is more complex and expensive to repair than a simple, flat roof. Green roofs, while environmentally beneficial, are at the higher end of roofing costs, ranging from $10 to $35 per square foot depending on factors like size and accessibility.

Cost of Replacement

If your shingles are beyond repair due to extensive damage, age, or widespread issues, replacement is necessary. Asphalt shingle roof replacement ranges from $3 to $5 per square foot, or $5,700 to $12,000 on average. This depends on factors like roof size and shingle quality. The total cost depends on the roof size (in square feet), the type of shingle (architectural shingles cost more than 3-tab shingles), and the shingle brand and quality. While replacement has a higher upfront cost, it offers long-term benefits, including better curb appeal, increased home value, improved energy efficiency, and superior protection from the elements. A new roof eliminates recurring problems associated with patching older, damaged shingles. Consider getting a Get Your Roof Assessment to evaluate your options.

Repair Costs

  • Range: $379 - $1,758
  • Includes labor and materials
  • Cost-effective for minor damage

Replacement Costs

  • Range: $5,700 - $12,000
  • Long-term benefits
  • Eliminates recurring issues

Insurance Coverage Options

Your insurance coverage can significantly reduce the cost of shingle repair or replacement. Roof insurance typically comes in two forms: actual cash value (ACV) and replacement cost value (RCV). ACV policies consider depreciation, meaning you receive the current value of the damaged shingles, not the cost of new ones. The older your roof, the less you'll receive. RCV policies cover the full cost of replacing damaged shingles with new materials of similar kind and quality, regardless of depreciation. However, RCV policies usually have higher premiums.

Evaluating Your Policy

Before deciding on repair or replacement, review your insurance policy. Look for specifics about roof damage coverage, including the types of damage covered (wind, hail, etc.) and any requirements regarding shingle performance. Some policies exclude specific types of damage or shingle issues. Contact your insurance provider to understand potential reimbursements and out-of-pocket expenses. This helps you budget effectively and avoid surprises.

Maximizing Insurance Benefits

To maximize your insurance benefits, thoroughly document the damage and any previous repairs. Photos and reports from roofing professionals support your claim. This documentation proves the extent of the damage and helps demonstrate that it's covered. Report the damage to your insurer promptly to expedite the claims process. Delays can lead to further damage and complicate your claim.

Warranty Considerations

Roofing warranties provide additional protection and can influence your decision. Most shingle warranties last 25-30 years, some up to 50 years. Some warranties, like lifetime limited warranties, cover single-family homes, while others, like 50-year warranties, apply to properties owned by organizations or used for multi-family housing. These warranties typically cover manufacturing defects and may have separate terms for wind resistance. This means curling or cracking due to manufacturing flaws might be covered, but wind damage might have different terms. Wind resistance terms within the warranty may not offer the same coverage as defects, and may have different time limits or restrictions. Learn more about roof maintenance.

Regional Installation Adaptations

Understanding regional adaptations is crucial for shingle longevity and performance. Different regions have unique climate, geography, and building codes. Addressing these factors prevents issues like shingles not laying flat. For example, the wrong underlayment in a humid climate can trap moisture, causing warping. This moisture can come from rain, humidity, or condensation. This section covers climate-specific requirements, geographic considerations, and local building codes that impact shingle installation. Tailoring the installation to regional demands achieves durable and aesthetically pleasing results. Considering a professional roof assessment can help identify potential issues before they become major problems. Get Your Roof Assessment

Climate-Specific Requirements

Regional climate significantly influences shingle installation and performance. In heavy snowfall areas, shingles need attention to ice dam prevention and moisture barriers. Ice dams form when snow melts and refreezes at the eaves, preventing runoff and causing water damage. This is problematic in colder climates with fluctuating temperatures. Regions with high temperatures and intense sunlight require UV degradation and thermal expansion resistant materials. UV degradation weakens shingles, increasing cracking. Thermal expansion, from temperature fluctuations, causes buckling. Climate-specific requirements ensure shingles withstand local conditions. Learn more about roof maintenance

  • Cold Climates: Requires robust insulation and ventilation to prevent ice dams. Proper ventilation keeps the roof deck cold and consistent, minimizing the freeze-thaw cycle that contributes to ice dam formation. This is achieved through proper attic ventilation, including soffit and ridge vents.
  • Hot Climates: Needs shingles with high UV resistance and proper ventilation to combat heat. UV rays degrade shingles, causing brittleness and cracks. Ventilation prevents heat buildup in the attic, which can damage shingles and impact energy efficiency.
  • Humid Areas: Demands moisture-resistant underlayments to prevent mold and mildew. A moisture-resistant underlayment acts as an extra barrier, protecting the roof deck from rot and shingles from warping. This is important in humid climates with consistent moisture.

Geographic Considerations

Geographic features influence shingle installation. Coastal regions experience high winds and salty air, requiring corrosion-resistant materials and wind-resistant techniques. Standard nails rust quickly in coastal environments, compromising the roof. Specialized sealant may be required. Mountainous areas, with steep slopes, require specialized methods for stability and water runoff. These methods might include longer nails and additional adhesive. The slope can affect underlayment choice and installation.

  • Coastal Areas: Use corrosion-resistant fasteners and wind-resistant shingles. These shingles often have stronger adhesive to withstand higher wind speeds and prevent uplift, crucial in hurricane-prone areas.
  • Mountainous Regions: Employ techniques for steep slopes and effective water runoff. Properly installed flashing and sealant prevent water infiltration. Gravity affects water flow on steeper slopes, requiring attention during installation.
  • Plains: Focus on wind resistance due to open landscapes. Consider impact-resistant shingles in hail-prone areas. Flat terrain increases wind speeds, stressing the roof.

Local Building Codes

Adhering to local building codes is essential. These codes address regional needs, including weather patterns. For example, codes in hurricane-prone areas mandate wind resistance ratings for roofing. Codes are based on historical weather data and are updated. Building codes may dictate shingle types, installation methods, and ventilation systems. Ignoring these can lead to premature roof failure and legal issues. Non-compliance can void insurance coverage. Obtain necessary permits and inspections.

  • Code Compliance: Ensures safety and longevity by meeting local standards. Check your local building department for specific codes before starting any roofing project.
  • Ventilation Requirements: Critical to prevent moisture buildup and extend roof life. Adequate ventilation regulates attic temperature and humidity, preventing mold and shingle deterioration. Proper ventilation improves energy efficiency.
  • Material Standards: Mandate specific materials based on regional conditions. These standards ensure materials withstand the local climate. This might include fire resistance, impact resistance, or wind uplift resistance.

By understanding and implementing these regional adaptations, homeowners and contractors optimize shingle performance, ensuring they lay flat and remain durable. This enhances aesthetic appeal and functional integrity.

Prevention and Maintenance

Ensuring new shingles lay flat and maintain their integrity requires preventive measures and ongoing maintenance. Addressing potential issues early can save homeowners time and money and prevent extensive roof damage. Proactive steps, like regular inspections, proper storage, and long-term care, enhance shingle lifespan and performance. These actions mitigate common roofing issues and protect your investment for years to come.

Regular Inspection Guidelines

Regular roof inspections are crucial for maintenance. Homeowners should visually inspect their roofs twice yearly, ideally in spring and fall. This helps identify potential problems before and after winter weather. Think of it as a check-up for your roof. During inspections, look for wear, like curling or missing shingles, which compromise water repellency. Curling shingles, for instance, lose effectiveness because lifted edges allow water underneath. Besides self-inspections, consider annual professional inspections, especially after major storms. Professionals have the tools and expertise to find hidden damage. According to industry standards, they often use standardized methods from organizations like ASTM (American Society of Testing and Materials) or SSPC (Steel Structures Painting Council) for thoroughness, specifying testing and calibration procedures for equipment. These inspections typically take 30-40 minutes. Share any photos or videos of damage with the inspector. Regular inspections, much like maintenance in construction projects, prevent small issues from becoming major problems, potentially requiring reconstruction. This proactive approach extends shingle life. Learn more about roof maintenance

Proper Storage Methods

Proper shingle storage before installation is vital for ensuring they lie flat and function correctly. Store shingles in a cool, dry place to prevent sticking and deformation. According to TAMKO, storing shingles in hot areas can cause warping, preventing them from lying flat and potentially creating water shedding issues. Stack shingles horizontally, avoiding direct sunlight and extreme temperatures. Ensure good ventilation in the storage area to reduce moisture and prevent mold or mildew growth, which can damage shingles. Following these guidelines prevents issues like difficulty separating shingles, which slows installation and potentially damages them, or misalignment during installation. Proper storage contributes to enhanced long-term performance, maximizing roof lifespan and effectiveness.

Storage Guidelines

  • Cool, dry location
  • Stack horizontally
  • Avoid direct sunlight

Prevention Benefits

  • Prevents sticking and warping
  • Enhances long-term performance
  • Maximizes roof lifespan

Long-term Care Tips

Long-term shingle care maintains their appearance and function. Trim overhanging tree branches to prevent damage and moisture buildup. Falling branches directly damage shingles, while overhanging branches trap moisture, encouraging moss and algae growth, shortening shingle life. Clean gutters prevent water backup and roof damage. Clogged gutters cause overflows, leading to leaks, especially during heavy rain. Consider applying a roof coating or sealant for extra protection against UV rays and weather, following proper safety standards and training. This extends shingle life and preserves color. Periodically review and update maintenance practices, checking manufacturer recommendations and industry best practices. This enhances shingle durability, ensuring they remain flat and effective throughout their lifespan. Get Your Roof Assessment

Professional Assessment Guide

When new shingles don't lay flat, it can cause water damage and look bad. It might also mean there are bigger problems that need fixing right away. A professional check-up is key to figuring out why this is happening and how to fix it. This guide will show you how to do a thorough check, including what to look for, how to keep good records, and tips for finding the right contractor.

Inspection Checklist

A good inspection is the first step to figuring out why your shingles aren't flat. Start by looking at your roof.

Visual Inspection

Check for shingles that are curled, missing, or broken. Curled shingles will look like they're bent up or down, like a cup or taco. Missing shingles leave gaps, letting water in. Damaged shingles might be cracked, torn, or messed up from hail or other things hitting them.

Installation Check

Look for signs of bad installation. Shingles should be in straight lines and overlap evenly, like bricks in a wall. Exposed nails can let water in and can rust, making your roof weaker.

Underlayment and Decking

Check the underlayment and decking for water damage or warping. These are often the reason shingles don't lay flat. A damaged underlayment might be discolored, moldy, or rotting. A warped deck might feel uneven or spongy when you walk on it (but it's best to avoid walking on a damaged roof and let the pros handle it).

Ventilation

Make sure your roof is well-ventilated. Poor ventilation can make your roof too hot and warp the shingles. Good ventilation lets hot air escape, keeping your attic and roof deck from getting too hot. This helps prevent the shingles from softening and bending. If you find problems, figuring out the cause can help you avoid them in the future. Just like in manufacturing, knowing what went wrong (like bad nailing or a bad underlayment) can prevent problems later on. Consider getting a roof assessment to identify potential issues early.

Inspection Steps

  • Visual inspection for curled or missing shingles
  • Check installation for straight lines and overlap
  • Inspect underlayment and decking for damage

Common Issues

  • Poor ventilation
  • Water damage or warping
  • Exposed nails

Documentation Requirements

Keeping good records is important. It helps you track problems now and for future checkups.

Record Keeping

Write down the date and time of each inspection, and what you find. Be specific, like "Five missing shingles on the north side, two feet from the chimney." Take pictures and videos of the damaged areas. Close-ups are good for showing small cracks or how much the shingles are curling.

Equipment Calibration

If you use any testing tools, make sure they are calibrated and follow industry standards like those from the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM). According to industry standards, these standards tell you how often to calibrate your tools, sometimes before each use or after a certain number of uses. They also tell you the right way to test, ensuring accurate results. Keeping good records helps with insurance claims and contractor assessments. Keep records of past roof work, too. This can help figure out if current problems are related to older repairs or installations.

Finding Qualified Contractors

Finding the right contractor is key to fixing your shingles.

Recommendations and Credentials

Ask local building associations or check directories for certified roofing professionals. Your local hardware store might have suggestions, too. Make sure the contractor is licensed and insured. This protects you if there are accidents and makes sure they follow local building codes. Check their experience by asking for references and looking at their past work.

Material Expertise

It's important to find a contractor who knows about your specific type of shingle. Installation methods can be different depending on the material. Some shingles need special nail patterns or ventilation. A good contractor should give you a detailed plan with timelines and costs. Ask questions about anything you don't understand, like the warranty or the materials they'll use. Learn more about roof maintenance to make informed decisions when hiring a contractor.

Comparing Bids

Getting multiple estimates helps you compare prices and services to make sure you're getting a fair deal. Manufacturers often have helpful resources and guides on the right way to install and maintain their products.

Future-Proofing Your Roof

A durable roof is essential for protecting your home. Future-proofing involves choosing the right materials, planning the installation carefully, and monitoring the weather. These steps help your roof last longer and withstand future weather challenges. This section offers practical advice to help you protect your investment and ensure your roof stands the test of time.

Material Selection Tips

Choosing the right roofing materials is the first step in future-proofing. Selecting durable shingles designed to resist various weather conditions is crucial. Synthetic underlayment, made from polyethylene or polypropylene polymers, offers superior protection against moisture compared to traditional felt. According to Dwayne Sloan, Technical Director at UL, this added protection is vital for preventing leaks and extending the life of your roof. The synthetic material acts as an additional barrier against water, even if your shingles are damaged. Shingle weight also matters. Heavier shingles, typically available in 15, 30, and 40-pound weights, generally offer enhanced protection and longevity. Like a thick winter coat, heavier shingles provide better resistance against impact and wind damage. Finally, look for materials tested and certified by organizations like UL for fire resistance, wind impact, and other environmental factors. These tests, which include simulations of hail and debris strikes, ensure the shingles meet industry standards. Learn more about roof maintenance

Material Selection

  • Choose durable shingles
  • Consider synthetic underlayment
  • Heavier shingles for better protection

Certification Standards

  • Look for UL certification
  • Tested for fire resistance
  • Ensures weather resistance

Installation Planning

Careful installation planning is key to preventing problems like shingles not lying flat. Before starting, use a checklist to ensure a smooth process. This checklist should include preparing the site. Clear the yard of debris to make finding dropped nails or shingles easier and move patio furniture to avoid damage. This prevents safety hazards and protects your belongings. Documenting the condition of your driveway beforehand with photos is also recommended. These photos provide evidence of any pre-existing damage, protecting you in case of disputes. The type of shingle also impacts installation. Three-tab shingles, being thinner and lighter than architectural shingles, require precise installation. Precise measurements, correct alignment, and consistent nailing techniques are crucial for proper interlocking and a flat appearance. Following these guidelines minimizes errors and ensures long-term performance. Get Your Roof Assessment

Weather Monitoring Strategies

Proactive weather monitoring is essential for protecting your roof. Climate change is causing more intense weather, including stronger monsoons and shifting storm tracks. These changes put increased stress on roofs. Regularly checking weather forecasts and scheduling roof work during stable weather is crucial. Avoid installations in extreme temperatures. Ideally, shingle installation should occur when the temperature is between 40°F and 90°F. Extreme heat or cold can affect shingle flexibility and adhesion. In colder weather, when shingles become brittle, warming them with a heat gun before installation can prevent cracking. Hold the heat gun a few inches away from the shingles, moving it constantly to avoid overheating and warping. Staying informed about weather patterns and taking precautions enhances your roof's resilience against unexpected weather events.

Disclaimer: This blog post is intended for informational purposes only and should not be considered professional roofing advice. Always consult with qualified roofing contractors and insurance professionals for specific guidance regarding your individual circumstances.

Kevin Kabaria
Previous

Roof Shingles Curling? Discover the Causes & Solutions
Next

Why Roofs Leak in Freezing Weather: Explained